Pdf challenges of cluster randomized trials researchgate. Cluster randomization trials crts are experimental studies in which intact social units clusters, such as families, schools or even entire cities, rather than independent individuals, are randomly allocated to intervention groups. Changing cluster composition in cluster randomised. For generality we shall refer to all these types of studies as cluster randomised trials crt. The pragmatic randomised controlled trial volume 8 issue 5 matthew hotopf skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. Basic or enhanced clinician training to improve adherence. Statistical methods for costeffectiveness analyses that use data. Developing appropriate methods for costeffectiveness. In cluster randomised trials, this is a special case of the approach to analysis recommended more generally for stepped wedge trials cluster randomised trials where outcomes are assessed at multiple time points, and different clusters switch over to the intervention at different times. A cluster randomized controlled trial of a clinical pathway. The method of randomization for clusterrandomized trials.
Economists have been combining theory and randomized controlled trials in a variety of other ways since the early experiments. Cluster randomised trials second edition discusses the design conduct and analysis of trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. Stratification, cluster randomized trial, sensitivity analysis, continuous. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation, with special attention given to evaluating the. We adjusted the sample size using an inflation factor of 1. Following this, identified records were merged into one. Use of clustering analysis in randomized controlled trials in. Clusterrandomized trials, in which health interventions are allocated randomly to intact clusters or communities rather than to individual subjects, are increasingly being used to evaluate disease control strategies both in industrialized and in developing countries. Cluster unit randomized trials office of behavioral and.
They are suitable when the intervention applies naturally to the cluster e. Cluster randomised trials in the medical literature. Power calculation for cluster randomised trials crt with. The pragmatic randomised controlled trial advances in. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation, with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectio. Cluster randomised trials, second edition discusses the design, conduct, and analysis of trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. Cluster randomised controlled trials vanderbilt university. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation, with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectious diseases. Internal and external validity of cluster randomised. Applying wolbachia to eliminate dengue full text view. The awed trial applying wolbachia to eliminate dengue to assess the efficacy of wolbachiainfected mosquito deployments to reduce dengue incidence in yogyakarta, indonesia.
Crt key features of the cluster randomised rialt i who, bmf, thap and stakeholders targeting at least 30% malaria incidence reduction i count of monthly malaria rapid diagnosis estt rdt based. They are sometimes known as group randomized trials. Cluster randomized trials with a small number of clusters. Randomized controlled trials are accepted as the gold standard for the evaluation of new health interventions. Review of 34 cluster randomised trials in primary care published in 2004 and 2005 in seven journals british medical journal, british journal of general practice, family practice, preventive. Pharmacists could help improve asthma control, reducing this burden. Regression analysis based on individual level data. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Cluster randomised controlled trials crcts are frequently used in health service evaluation. Analysis of the stepped wedge cluster randomized trial. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation with special attention given to evaluating the. Whilst many characteristics of cluster randomized trials are in common with patient randomized trials, the adoption of a cluster randomized design has some implications for the design, conduct and analysis of the trial. In a crxo trial, not only are clusters of individuals rather than individuals themselves randomized to trial arms, but also each cluster participates in each arm of the trial at least once in separate periods.
The need for consent by individual study subjects is deemed of particular concern for individual cluster trials. A cluster randomised control trial to evaluate the. Pitfalls of and controversies in cluster randomization trials. Sensitivity of methods for analyzing continuous outcome from. The aim of itt analysis is to maintain this comparability during analysis. Apr 24, 2017 the economic burden of asthma, which relates to the degree of control, is 5 billion annually in italy. Medical statistics group, scharr university of sheffield. Cluster randomized trials crts are trials in which groups of participants, rather than the participants themselves, are randomized. In the evaluation of new drugs and vaccines, treatments are in general allocated randomly to individual subjects, and methods for the design and analysis of such trials are well established. My expertise is in correlated data analysis, study design, and statistical epidemiology, with a focus on cluster randomized trials. Jan 14, 2009 cluster randomised trials discusses the design, conduct, and analysis of health trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments.
Why would you want to do a cluster randomised trial. Thus, most sections of this protocol support tool apply directly to cluster randomized trials. How important is randomisation in a stepped wedge trial. The rst malaria tsab based entomological trial with primary epidemiological end points 2. The stepped wedge sw cluster randomized controlled trial crct design is. An intervention to optimise the delivery of integrated.
Aug 12, 2014 the cluster randomized crossover crxo design is gaining popularity in trial settings where individual randomization or parallel group cluster randomization is not feasible or practical. Factors influencing loss of precision cluster randomization trials 1. Cluster randomised controlled trials crcts are trials which randomise groups of patients rather than individual patients. Methodological bias in cluster randomised trials bmc. Choosing appropriate analysis methods for cluster randomised crossover trials with binary outcome. Design of vaccine efficacy trials during public health. However, where the number of clusters are fixed in advance, but where it is possible to increase the number of individuals within.
Cluster randomised controlled trials are also known as cluster randomised trials, 2 group randomised trials, 3 4 and place randomized trials. Design and analysis issues in clusterrandomized trials of. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Cluster randomised controlled trials are also known as cluster randomised trials, group randomised trials, and placerandomized trials.
Cluster randomised trials can be susceptible to a range of methodological problems. Cluster randomization trials, in which intact groups of individuals are randomized to receive different interventions, have been increasingly adopted by public health researchers over the past 2 decades after publication of a seminal article by cornfield1 and the extensive methodological developments stimulated by this article. Robust analysis of stepped wedge trials using cluster. In a randomised controlled trial, contamination is defined as the receipt of active intervention amongst participants in the control arm. In parallel cluster randomized controlled trials crcts, study sites e.
After presenting some basic concepts, hayes and moulton focus on the clustering aspect of the design. Sample size calculations for cluster randomised controlled. The cluster randomized crossover crxo design is gaining popularity in trial settings where individual randomization or parallel group cluster randomization is not feasible or practical. In this paper we discuss the issues that can lead to bias in cluster trials. They generally have lower power for a given sample size because of correlations between observations on people in the same cluster but have some key advantages that address. This cluster randomized clinical trial finds improved body mass index in groups of children whose physicians receive computerized clinical decision support and.
This cluster randomised, multicentre, controlled trial in adult patients with. Stepped wedge cluster randomized controlled trial designs. Attrition in a cluster randomized crossover trial implies a loss of efficiency. Cluster randomised control trial at 18 primary care clinics in south africa. To illustrate this, we focus on the issue of cluster merging, considering the impact on the design, analysis and interpretation of trial outcomes. Cluster randomised controlled trial of a theorybased. The main consort statement provides recommendations for reporting parallel group randomized trials, in which individual participants are randomly assigned to health care interventions. Design and analysis of cluster randomization trials donner in health research. Interventions will be conducted at the classroom level and be repeated every six months for four years eight interventions. Effectiveness of childhood obesity interventions jama. Cluster unit randomized trials the office of behavioral. Methods and analysis mwellcare trial is a multicentre, cluster randomised controlled trial evaluating the clinical and costeffectiveness of a mhealth system and nurse managed care for people with hypertension and diabetes in rural india.
Pragmatic and grouprandomized trials in public health and. Crt designs are used not only to evaluate group interventions but also individual interventions where group level effects are relevant. I have been the principal statistician on numerous international field trials, including vitamin a and hib vaccine trials with over 14,000 and 50,000 participants respectively. Cluster randomised trials hayes rj, moulton lh 2009 isbn. Examples might include randomising communities to different public health interventions, randomising practitioners to different methods of treating patients, or randomising whole bodies when the target is an organ such as the eyes, kidneys or teeth. A cluster randomized trial is one in which groups of subjects are randomized rather than individuals. The clusters might be families, schools, factories, villages, cities, arbitrary geographical areas or some other predefined group. Grouprandomized trials in public health and medicine. How to design, analyse and report cluster randomised trials in medicine and health related research. Request pdf how to design, analyse and report cluster randomised trials in medicine and health services research a complete guide to understanding cluster randomised trials. The use of the cluster randomized crossover design in. Current and controversial issues in design and analysis design and analysis of clinical trials.
In cluster randomized trials, intact social units or groups of individuals, such as medical practices, schools, or entire communities rather than individual themselves are randomly. Analysis of a cluster randomised trial in education this is an expanded version of a talk given to the workshop on cluster randomised trials at the first conference on randomised controlled trials in the social sciences, university of york, september 2006. Bayesian evaluation of informative hypotheses in cluster. The traditional approach to the analysis of cluster randomized trials has been to calculate a summary measure for each cluster, such as a cluster mean or proportion. Jan 08, 2016 cluster randomized clinical trials crt are trials in which the unit of randomization is not a participant but a group e. National diabetes audits in the uk show room for improvement in the quality of care delivered to people with type 2 diabetes in primary care.
Jan 12, 2009 cluster randomised trials discusses the design, conduct, and analysis of health trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. This contradicts the design effects reported in hayes and moulton 2. Pdf cluster randomized trials are trials that randomize clusters of people, rather than individuals. Detailed statistical analysis plan for a cluster randomised. Eldridge, prof david forman, prof jeremy grimshaw, prof richard hayes, prof. Cluster randomised controlled trials of programmes delivered to school. When patients in a single study are treated by several therapists, there is good reason to suspect that the variation in outcome will be smaller for patients treated in the same group than for patients treated in different groups.
If a smaller number of clusters are included, stratified or matched randomisation can increase comparability between trial arms. Because each cluster then provides only one data point, the data can be considered to be independent, allowing standard statistical tests to be used. Pdf over the last century, the randomized clinical trial has become the gold standard for interventional studies. In addition to the usual rationale for this design, there are a number of other advantages that are peculiar to the study of infectious diseases. Sample size computations for such trials need to take. Introduction and scope cluster randomised trials crts are becoming increasingly important in health technology assessment. Analysis of cluster randomized trials in primary care. Stoney, laura lee johnson, in principles and practice of clinical research fourth edition, 2018.
Grouprandomized also known as cluster randomized trials are those trials where the unit of randomization is one of the several types of groups rather than an individual. In cluster randomised trials, randomisation increases internal study validity. Cluster randomised trials crts are much less common than traditional clinical trials, in which individual patients are randomly assigned to the different treatment arms. Cluster randomised trials, second edition johns hopkins. As defined by hayes and moulton in 2009 6, in a crct, groups are. Ceas based on randomized controlled trials rcts, where individual patients are randomized, have wellestablished methods. The second phase, the results of which are reported here, was a stratified cluster randomised trial done in a realworld setting to compare the introduction of rdts in two intervention packages involving different content and modes of clinician training to routine care where microscopy is. The loss of efficiency due to attrition of subjects in a cohort design is largest for small number of subjects per cluster period, but it may be repaired to a large degree by increasing the number of subjects per cluster period or by replacing those. A cluster randomised controlled trial with at least 36 schools randomised to receive an implementation intention intervention targeting reducing smoking initiation intervention group or increasing homework control group. Recruitment and retention of participants in randomised. Cluster randomised trials short course unit scharr the. Cluster randomised trials evidencebased management. Cluster randomized trials crt in which the unit of randomization is a group of participants 3,4, or cluster are relevant for interventions applied at the level of the group, and may offer some advantages in trials enrolling participants with mcc. To identify papers relevant to the methodology for cluster randomised trials published between 2004 and 2010, we undertook an electronic search of medline, embase, and the cochrane methodology register and a full text search of statistics in medicine, clinical trials, contemporary clinical trials, and bmc medical research methodology.
How to design, analyse and report cluster randomised. Cluster randomized trial an overview sciencedirect topics. The effects of clustering in randomized controlled trials rcts and the resulting potential violation of assumptions of independence are now well recognized. Recent articles have considered stepped wedge trials as part of a broader class of cluster randomised trials where two or more independent crosssections are taken from each cluster at fixed times, with all participants in any given crosssection in any given cluster receiving either the experimental or the control treatment. Simple sample size calculation for clusterrandomized trials. Comparative effectiveness of childhood obesity interventions in pediatric primary care. This paper discusses the application of the clusterrandomized trial crt design to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions against infectious diseases. Cluster randomization should be used when it would be impractical or impossible to assign and correctly deliver the experimental and control treatments to individual study participants. Moulton estimated delivery 312 business days format hardcover condition brand new there is an increasing need for new health interventions to be rigorously evaluated through randomized controlled trials, which have become the gold standard for intervention studies. Jul 24, 2017 on march 29, 2017, edward liechty, md gave a presentation on the unique ethical issues that can arise from cluster randomized clinical trials. Understanding and misunderstanding randomized controlled.
Analysis of cluster level summaries compute summary measure for each cluster. Design and analysis of cluster randomization trials in. The trials help build and test theory and theory in turn can answer questions about new settings and populations that we cannot answer by simple extrapolation or generalization of the trial. An intervention to optimise the delivery of integrated tuberculosis and hiv services at primary care clinics. Store search search title, isbn and author cluster randomised trials by richard j. Cluster randomised trials discusses the design, conduct, and analysis of health trials that randomise groups of individuals to different treatments. The rct aims to measure and compare the outcomes of two or more clinical interventions. Jb is an investigator on a trial of the effect of ivermectin on malaria transmission. My strategy was to choose some journals likely to contain cluster randomised trials, such as the british medical journal, lancet, journal of the royal college of general practitioners, etc.
The intervention was placement of a nurse tbhiv integration officer to facilitate provision of integrated tbhiv services, and a lay health worker tb screening officer to facilitate tb screening for 24 months. The full text of this article hosted at is unavailable due to technical difficulties. These problems are not commonly recognised by many researchers. Avoiding unnecessary mathematical detail, the book covers basic concepts underlying the. However, statistical methods for ceas of crts have received limited attention. Concepts and methodologies download ebook design and analysis of clinical trials. The video of the presenation can be accessed with the.
The randomised controlled trial rct is a simple and powerful tool of research. Lhm and rh receive royalties from sales of their textbook on cluster randomised trials. If enough clusters are randomised, an unadjusted analysis should be unbiased. Dec 15, 2016 the healthy lifestyles programme help trial is being conducted to determine whether a novel schoolbased intervention is effective and costeffective in preventing obesity in 910 yearold children. This article describes the detailed statistical analysis plan for the help trial, including an amendment and rationale for amendment made to originally planned sensitivity analyses. But this strategy is typical of many cluster randomized trials. A study protocol for a clustered randomised controlled. Design and analysis of cluster randomization trials in health. Analysis of cluster randomised trials with an assessment.
Rj hayes and s bennett background clusterrandomized trials, in which health interventions are allocated randomly to intact clusters or communities rather than to individual subjects, are increasingly being used to evaluate disease control strategies both in industrialized and in developing countries. Cluster randomised trials request pdf researchgate. In trials with fewer than 30 clusters, cluster by cluster data should be presented. The sample size calculation was performed according to standard criteria for cluster randomized trials. It explores the advantages of cluster randomization, with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectious diseases. Randomized clinical trials of nonpharmacological treatments pdf cluster randomised trials second edition download ebook cluster randomised trials, second edition pdf free cancer clinical trials. It explores the advantages of cluster randomisation with special attention given to evaluating the effects of interventions against infectious diseases. Cluster randomised trials, second edition thoroughly describes the aspects of crt designs and the analysis of data from such trials. The consort extension for cluster trials was updated in 2012 to be inline with consort 2010 and is available for download below. Assuming an average cluster size, required sample sizes are readily computed for both binary and continuous outcomes, by estimating a design effect or inflation factor. In cluster trials, all participants within a cluster are assigned to the same intervention. In individually randomised trials, randomisation and allocation concealment aim to prevent selection bias and allow for the comparability of groups at the beginning of the study. Efficiency decreases with an increase of the attrition rate. A cluster randomised controlled trial is a type of randomised controlled trial in which groups of subjects as opposed to individual subjects are randomised.
704 810 622 1340 1016 1108 1170 428 601 987 1548 1337 87 27 1039 537 1082 123 1419 362 1505 766 1216 737 1530 872 1441 1322 1170 244 1319 1499 1105 453 655 547 380